Effective Phone Screening: Tips & Strategies for 2025

In today's competitive talent landscape, phone screening interviews have become strategic tools rather than simple preliminary conversations. Artificial intelligence will handle 95% of initial candidate screening in 2025, [1] making human phone screenings more valuable for assessing soft skills and cultural fit. For recruiters managing hybrid and remote hiring, mastering phone screenings is key to identifying top talent early in the process.

What Is Phone Screening?

A phone screening is a brief, structured conversation between a recruiter and a job candidate, serving as the first step in the interview process. Typically lasting 15-20 minutes, it's designed to quickly assess whether a candidate meets basic qualifications and is worth advancing to more comprehensive interview rounds.

Key Purposes of Phone Screening

Initial Qualification Check

• Verify resume accuracy and basic requirements
• Confirm availability, salary expectations, and logistics
• Assess communication skills and professionalism

Mutual Fit Assessment

• Gauge candidate's genuine interest in the role
• Evaluate cultural alignment and work style preferences
• Allow candidates to ask initial questions about the company

Efficient Filtering

• Reduce time-to-hire by identifying strong candidates early [2]
• Save resources by screening out mismatched applicants before in-person interviews
• Typically eliminates 60-70% of candidates from further consideration [3]

Conducting a Phone Screen Interview

Conducting a phone screen interview is a key step in the recruitment pipeline. This initial screening helps you determine if a candidate meets the basic job requirements before proceeding to more extensive interviews. Here are some tips and strategies to effectively prepare for a phone screen interview:

Step 1: Shortlist candidates

Before the phone screen interview, carefully examine the candidate's resume to identify their relevant work experience, skills, and qualifications that match the job requirements. This will enable you to customize your interview questions accordingly.

Manatal's AI-powered screening capabilities can analyze resumes and applications to identify candidates who best match your role requirements and rank candidates based on the criteria you select.

{{cta}}

Step 2: Prepare screening questions

Compile a set of pertinent questions to pose to the candidate during the phone screen interview. These questions should center around the candidate's background, skills, and reasons for applying to the position. For guidance on crafting interview questions, refer to our tips on high-quality phone interview questions. Consider incorporating behavioral and situational inquiries to evaluate how the candidate handles specific scenarios.

Background and Experience Verification

• "Walk me through your current role and key responsibilities."
• "What initially attracted you to this position with our company?"
• "How does this opportunity align with your career goals?"

Availability and Logistics

• "What is your current notice period, and when would you be available to start?"
• "Are you comfortable with [remote/hybrid/in-office] work arrangements?"
• "Do you have any scheduling constraints for potential follow-up interviews?"

Compensation and Benefits Alignment

• "What are your salary expectations for this role?"
• "Are there specific benefits or workplace policies that are important to you?"
• "How does this opportunity compare to other positions you're considering?"

Cultural Fit and Communication Skills

• "Describe your ideal work environment and management style."
• "How do you handle competing priorities and tight deadlines?"
• "What questions do you have about our company culture or this role?"

Step 3: Schedule the Interview

Send calendar invites with clear call details, including phone numbers, expected duration, and any materials candidates should review beforehand. Provide multiple time slot options across different days to accommodate varying schedules, and always include backup contact information in case of technical difficulties.

Manatal allows integration with email providers like Gmail and Outlook, enabling workflow automation such as sending personalized emails.

Step 4: Note your data points

Make it a point to jot down notes during the phone screen interview for future reference. Record any key highlights, strengths, or areas of concern that could impact your decision on advancing the candidate in the recruitment process.

You can create collaborative notes in Manatal ATS on candidate profiles, jobs, clients, leads, contacts, or any other object with the ability to tag your team. Highlight important tasks, contract signing instructions, or any other information with full support for multi-user collaboration and editability.

Step 5: Follow Up and Maintain Your Talent Pipeline

79% of candidates will reapply if they receive feedback, even after being rejected.[4] After the phone screen interview, ensure you reach out to candidates to offer feedback and outline the next steps. Maintain professional and courteous communication, even if candidates are not chosen to progress further in the recruitment process. Create segments for candidates who demonstrated strong potential but weren't quite ready, those who might be perfect for different departments, or individuals whose timeline doesn't align with current needs but could be valuable later.

Maintaining Professionalism

• Maintain a professional demeanor: When conducting the phone screen interview, uphold a professional atmosphere throughout the discussion. Ensure you are in a quiet, unobtrusive environment and communicate clearly and professionally to convey a sense of professionalism to the candidate.
• Demonstrating Active Listening: Active listening plays a crucial role in a phone screen interview. Give full attention to the candidate's responses, and ask follow-up questions to clarify any points or delve deeper into their answers. This will help you obtain more insights into the candidate's qualifications and suitability for the role.
• Offer informative guidance: As a recruiter, it is important to provide candidates with comprehensive details about the company, the job position, and the subsequent steps in the hiring process. This will assist candidates in gaining a clearer perspective of the opportunity and determining if it aligns with their career objectives.
• Evaluate cultural fit: Utilize the phone screen interview as an avenue to assess candidates' cultural compatibility with the organization. Pose questions about their work approach, communication style, and teamwork tactics to gauge their suitability for the company culture.

Mistakes to Avoid During a Phone Screen Interview

• Lack of preparation: One common mistake recruiters make during phone screen interviews is not adequately preparing for the conversation. This can lead to a disorganized and unproductive interview, potentially causing the candidate to lose interest in the role. Therefore, it’s a good idea to review the candidate's resume, prepare relevant questions, and familiarize yourself with the job description before the call.
• Not setting clear expectations: Another mistake is failing to communicate the purpose and expectations of the phone screen interview to the candidate. It is important to explain the interview process, timeline, and next steps to ensure that candidates know what to expect and can adequately prepare for the discussion.
• Poor communication skills: You should be mindful of your communication skills during a phone screen interview. Talking too fast, using jargon, or interrupting candidates can lead to misunderstandings and a negative candidate experience. Instead, speak, listen actively, and maintain a professional demeanor throughout the conversation.
• Asking inappropriate questions: Questions related to race, religion, marital status, age, or disability are off-limits and can potentially lead to discrimination claims. Stick to job-related questions that assess candidates' qualifications and fit for the role.
• Lack of engagement: Remember, a phone screen interview is your opportunity to engage with candidates and assess their interest in the position. Failing to show enthusiasm, ask follow-up questions, or actively listen to the candidate's responses can give the impression that you’re not interested in engaging in a conversation with candidates. Therefore, demonstrate genuine interest and engagement throughout the conversation.
• Rushing through the interview: Rushing through the phone screen interview to save time is not the right way to wrap up your task. It’s a must to take your time to assess candidates' qualifications, experience, and fit for the role. All of these aspects will help you make informed decisions.

Conclusion

Effective phone screening in 2025 blends human insight with technology to enhance hiring outcomes and develop talent pipelines. Utilizing AI-powered tools, such as Manatal's ATS platform, transforms phone screening into a strategic advantage by automating tasks and allowing recruiters to focus on building connections and making informed decisions. Positive candidate screening experiences boost an organization's reputation, whereas poor interactions can harm recruitment efforts. As recruitment evolves, mastering phone screening with strategic questioning, efficient processes, and thoughtful follow-ups is crucial for successful hiring.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How long should a phone screening last?

A: A phone screening should typically last between 15 and 30 minutes. This timeframe is sufficient to cover basic qualifications, gauge initial interest, and determine if the candidate warrants moving forward in the hiring process. Keeping it brief respects both the candidate's and recruiter's time while still allowing for meaningful evaluation of key criteria.

Q: What questions should be asked in a phone screening?

A: Phone screening questions should focus on basic qualifications, availability, salary expectations, and motivation. Common questions include verifying work experience, asking about specific skills relevant to the role, discussing availability for interviews and start dates, confirming location and willingness to work on-site or remotely, and understanding the candidate's interest in the position and company. Keep questions straightforward and factual rather than behavioral.

Q: Is phone screening the same as an interview?

A: No, phone screening is not the same as a full interview. Phone screening is a preliminary filtering step designed to quickly assess basic qualifications and mutual interest before investing time in a comprehensive interview. It's typically shorter, less detailed, and focuses on fundamental requirements rather than in-depth behavioral questions, technical assessments, or cultural fit evaluations that occur in formal interviews.

Q: What happens after the phone screening?

A: After a phone screening, qualified candidates typically advance to the next stage of the hiring process, which might include in-person or video interviews, technical assessments, panel interviews, or meetings with hiring managers. Candidates who don't meet the basic requirements are usually notified that they won't be moving forward. The specific next steps depend on the company's hiring process and the complexity of the role.

Q: Can AI tools be used for phone screening?

A: Yes, AI tools can be used for phone screening through automated phone systems, chatbots, or video screening platforms that can ask predetermined questions and evaluate responses. These tools can help scale the screening process and provide initial filtering based on specific criteria. However, they work best when combined with human oversight, as they may miss nuanced responses or cultural fit indicators that experienced recruiters can identify.

—

Citations

[1] MSH

[2] Starred

[3] XYPN

[4] SelectSoftware Reviews